Please help me compile empirical data on invasion parameters and souls gained in invasions. The questions I'm trying to answer are: (1) How many souls do you gain when you win a pvp match? (2) What are the precise invasion parameters for each method of invasion (cracked red, red orb, red soapstone, blue orb, darkmoon ring, and forest covenent ring)?
We all have opinions on this, but anecdotal stories are all over the place. Some people insist souls gained are a function of SL and whether you are a host or a phantom, while others insist that it must be related to souls held. I always thought it was the former, but I confess that I have my doubts. Regarding invasion parameters, the conventional wisdom seems to be that DWs (cracked and orbs) can invade up to 10% below their level or any amount above their level; DMs using a blue orb can invade up to 10% above their level or any amount below their level; forest invaders either have no cap or have a DW-style cap (10% below or any amount above); and DMs using a ring either have the blue orb parameters of the forest invader parameters.
I'm looking for hard data to support of refute the above theories. Here are some things that would help: (1) Have you ever invaded a host and received 0 souls upon victory? If so, which method of invasion? (2) Have you ever tested invasion parameters or souls gained with someone you know and trust (I want to stay away from your experiences asking random people about their SL, because they may not be honest about this)? If so, what were the results? (3) Have you every invaded and received more than 1.2 million souls upon victory? (4) Have you ever been invaded in the forest or dark anor londo at very low level (SL1-10)? If so, do recall how many souls you won if you defeated the invader? (5) Have you successfuly invaded with the red orb, cracked red, forest ring, or darkmoon ring with a charcter higher than SL300? How frequently? Which method?
Any other data are welcome, as are suggestions for testing. Your random opinions are also fine, but I'm on a quest for hard data here. :cyclops: