by TheMeInTeam Wed Jun 26, 2013 12:03 am
your next step should be to pick one of the above swords, make it +15 and get the correct stats. (and then tell me if you'll ever go elemental upgrade again ;P)
Elemental is great for most builds that are significantly below 100. Otherwise you can't really get a decent amount of HP/Stamina and still do respectable damage. The split damage really hurts though. This is why I would either recommend *very* fast hitting weapons with good critical (dagger, BK, rapier, estoc, those kinds of things) OR a very large weapon like the Zweihander (it has enough oomph in both physical and elemental that the damage is still quite fearsome).
Even at 100, an elemental can make plenty of sense if you're also a caster, especially one not relying heavily on buffs.
As for OP's question, I'd recommend he just stick with the claymore; the others aren't going to do much more damage and the clay's moveset is solid as many have pointed out. I never used greatswords much until a recent Zweihander kick, and man is the zwei fun. I'm not sure why ANYBODY fights with it locked on though
. It's not the most exciting moveset on a 16str/10dex build 2 handing it (swing sideways, kick, or overhead chop), but the dead-angling and sweeping hits without much tell before the swing starts where the unlocked wielder will swing it are very nice. Flattens a lot of PvE mobs too. I now understand why "the legend" uses a chaos zwei.
However, chaos or lightning are also excellent on the large/great clubs, and some big axes. For the largest of the axes or hammers however you need so much str to wield them that you're almost maxing scaling anyway, so elemental makes less sense there.