^Concerning situations like this I think I may have to consider the definition of what 'active' is.
This is Rant your situation to me presents like this- Yes there are members, though not enough to make the cut (I count 4). Are playing with their covenant toons? Also yes. However, is the covenant itself active? I think that's a bit questionable- No events since inception. No currently planned events. Noone have even spoken in the thread for over two months.
Also as I specified in the OP, membership needs to be of at least 5 members (and as of now, activity within the covenant as a whole needs to be demonstrated) for the covenant to make the cut.
Apologies that I'm being harsh here, but like I said earlier on, 7/8 active covenants with a good and active membership is better than 20 small covs with 2 or 3 members not really doing anything.
Ideally I'd like there to be 1 user covenant for each in-game covenant (minus WoW), but sadly some covenants can't generate the interest, or have failed (Gravesworn, Izalith)
Last edited by Serious_Much on Fri May 24, 2013 1:06 pm; edited 1 time in total