Soul of Sif [Greatshield of Artorias] RESOLVED!

I'm on NG++ I just killed Smough and the other guy, and I'm supposed to go to see the giant blacksmith cause I need him to forge the last 'weapon' with Sif's soul, which actually is a shield for me.
I gave Andre the Large Ember to go to +10 and when I go back to the Giant blacksmith there's nowhere I can forge the Greatshield of Artorias.
I tried with the Buckler and the Gargoyle's shield... and both are on the list...

Do you know why it doesn't work??

I'm really pissed cause it's my last weapon, to win the last trophy before the platinum.

Are you sure the shields you're trying to upgrade are already +10? Make sure, also I don't know if those shields work but I can confirm that at least the Eagle Shield works.

Also, it's impossible to get the Knight's Honor Trophy (all unique weapons) in NG++, at least by yourself. You need to go at least half of NG+++ to get it. Because you need to forge 3 weapons out of Sif's Soul. The Cursed Greatsword of Artorias, the Greatsword of Artorias (non-cursed version), and the Greatshield of Artorias. Just to let you know.

So you need to go NG+++ and kill the Gargoyles and Quelaag to be able to pass Sen's Fortress, then Anor Londo, then kill Sif and forge the weapon in Anor Londo.

I'll try with the eagle shield later in the night
NG +++ ?
But.. I already forged the the Greatsword of Artorias in my very first game, The Cursed Greatsword of Artorias in NG + , why would I have to go till NG +++ ? I should be able to forge the shield in NG ++ right now, shouldn't I?

Bgunners wrote:I'll try with the eagle shield later in the night
NG +++ ?
But.. I already forged the the Greatsword of Artorias in my very first game, The Cursed Greatsword of Artorias in NG + , why would I have to go till NG +++ ? I should be able to forge the shield in NG ++ right now, shouldn't I?

Srry, it was an error, indeed you can get it at NG++. Don't worry, sorry. I just misread the +.

still not working...
I'm going to the undead asylum and then I'll go to the painted world of ariamis and i'll try again maybe i need to go to those 2 places before...

nope

I DID IIIIIIT
So, it seems I had to save and free BH Logan in Sen's Fortress, I just did it and I can now forge Demon's weapons
I won all the trophies I'm very happy lol