Hi im wondering, assuming the following criteria, which variation of the Reinforced Club will do most damage.

Weapon in question is as said +15 reinforced club vs + chaos or lightning+5 reinforced club...

assuming...

1: No buffs are used on the +15 club (no CMW, Resins etc)

2: Str is at 40 for maximum scaling

3: 2handing the weapon

Which one would dish out most damage per hit with these criteria? And how big would the difference be?

The lightning club would have 484 damage and the normal scaling one would have 438. Here on paper the lightning club obviously wins, but since im so confused about how damage is calculated i woudl like to know which one would actually cause most damage per hit?

Appreciate it, thanks in advance.

Weapon in question is as said +15 reinforced club vs + chaos or lightning+5 reinforced club...

assuming...

1: No buffs are used on the +15 club (no CMW, Resins etc)

2: Str is at 40 for maximum scaling

3: 2handing the weapon

Which one would dish out most damage per hit with these criteria? And how big would the difference be?

The lightning club would have 484 damage and the normal scaling one would have 438. Here on paper the lightning club obviously wins, but since im so confused about how damage is calculated i woudl like to know which one would actually cause most damage per hit?

Appreciate it, thanks in advance.