[Spoilers] NEED HELP, Strange Bug, Already killed Manus...

I saw Dusk on the floor. I talked to her repeated times but she didn't say anything. So I left, and came back and she was gone. Then I went to Darkroot and summoned her and she say that a long time ago in the past Artorias saved her from the Abyss, or at least that is what she believes because her sense were harmed at the time; and she said that I resembled the being who saved her, but then she said it couldn't be possible because it was centuries ago.

Then I went to talk to the Giant Mushroom at Oolacile Sanctuary but she does not have any new dialogue options. I read that she rewards you with 3 unique mushrooms that regenrate health over time but she doesn't seem to realize I already saved her. I'm missing something? I already killed the Sanctuary Guardian, Artorias, Kalameet, and now Manus...

Nope, there's nothing after you kill Manus.

you have to kill her for the mushrooms.

nemesismonkey wrote:you have to kill her for the mushrooms.

I read in other pages that that's her reward. I didn't tried killing her, but it wouldn't make sense she doesn't even have a dialogue about how she was saved (even if she doesn't know it was you).

Also anybody tried killing Dusk while she is on the floor in the Chasm of the Abyss?

ChizFreak wrote:Also anybody tried killing Dusk while she is on the floor in the Chasm of the Abyss?

You're heartless you know that?

Bcc17 wrote:

ChizFreak wrote:Also anybody tried killing Dusk while she is on the floor in the Chasm of the Abyss?

You're heartless you know that?

Anything for the sake of knowledge.

Also I manage to find one Elizabeth's Mushroom in the Royal Forest. I will upload a vid later about how to find it. Also I found another Illusory wall in the Oolacile Township that uncovers with light, just like the one with the silver pendant. This is one is just a shortcut to save you a jump to get to the chest with a red titanite.

Sounds like a bug. Probably because you left the area and talked with Dusk in the regular timeline before talking to Liz back at the shrine. Sorry I don't have any practical advice on how to fix that.

How are the Mushrooms anyway? I haven't actually used any of mine!

I think you have to answer 'yes' to elizabeth's quest to get the mushroom gift for saving dusk.

dialogues (and spoilers): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XWYdkaN7ahg
mushroom effect: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i8TGWghsScc

ublug wrote:
mushroom effect: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i8TGWghsScc

Wolverine Mode Activated!

Gah, can't wait till people start duplicating items and using that in PvP...

ChizFreak wrote:Also anybody tried killing Dusk while she is on the floor in the Chasm of the Abyss?

I did today,

Spoiler:

ublug wrote:I think you have to answer 'yes' to elizabeth's quest to get the mushroom gift for saving dusk.

dialogues (and spoilers): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XWYdkaN7ahg
mushroom effect: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i8TGWghsScc

I said yes, so... I don't know... Maybe if I keep talking to her, right now I'm getting dialogues I didn't get before of other characters (like from Chester and Artorias). Maybe if I exhaust her other dialogues the rescue dialogue will trigger.

I killed her before litting the bonfire, because I was expecting it to attack me. Got the three mushrooms. If she isn't giving them to you, just kill her. It's not like you benefit of having her alive in any way now

Wrenchfarm wrote:

ublug wrote:
mushroom effect: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i8TGWghsScc

Wolverine Mode Activated!

Gah, can't wait till people start duplicating items and using that in PvP...

Been hearing about this happening already.

The other day I ended up using one in a duel when the other player flasked a few times in a row ---- dayumn.... it's good that there is only a limited number available each play-through. But yeah, dupers are going to have a field day with this.